In the world of rugby, the #5 lock is often regarded as the tactical mastermind of the forward pack. These second rowers are key strategists, orchestrating the lineouts and providing the vital link between the forwards and backs. Their roles may not always be as glamorous as some, but they’re crucial to any team’s success. With so many legends in the position, picking the greatest #5 locks was a tough call — and the Southern Hemisphere certainly dominates this list. Without further ado, here’s a look at the top five #5 locks in rugby history.
1. Victor Matfield (South Africa)
Victor Matfield’s legacy as one of the greatest locks of all time is solidified through his mastery of the lineout and his tactical brilliance on the field. Known for his unmatched ability to read the opposition’s plays, Matfield was a key figure in South Africa’s success during his career. His contributions went beyond the set piece, with slick handling, strong defense, and incredible leadership as a captain. Matfield’s rugby IQ was off the charts, and he consistently brought the best out of his teammates. His résumé includes a Rugby World Cup title, three Super Rugby championships, and 127 caps for South Africa. Undoubtedly, Matfield’s place in rugby history is firmly cemented.
Achievements: Rugby World Cup (2007), 3x Super Rugby titles, 3x Tri-Nations titles, British & Irish Lions series win (2009), 127 caps for South Africa.
2. John Eales (Australia)
John Eales, affectionately known as “Nobody” because “Nobody’s perfect,” was a lock ahead of his time. A true rugby icon, he was a blueprint for the modern-day lock, known for his incredible versatility and leadership on the field. Eales had a unique skill set — he could kick penalties and conversions with remarkable accuracy, a trait few locks can claim. His lineout prowess, coupled with his ability to read the game and lead his team with composure, made him a true one-of-a-kind player. With two World Cups, multiple Bledisloe Cup titles, and 86 caps for Australia, Eales’ legacy is unmatched.
Achievements: 2x Rugby World Cups (1991, 1999), multiple Bledisloe Cup titles, Tri-Nations titles, 86 caps for Australia.
3. Sam Whitelock (New Zealand)
Sam Whitelock’s name is synonymous with consistency and excellence in the lock position. As a cornerstone of the All Blacks’ forward pack, he played a pivotal role in New Zealand’s dominance from 2010 to 2018. Whitelock was a key figure in the lineout and was known for his unmatched work rate and leadership. Alongside Brodie Retallick, he formed one of rugby’s most formidable lock partnerships. With two Rugby World Cup titles, numerous Rugby Championship and Super Rugby victories, and 153 caps for the All Blacks, Whitelock is truly one of the greats.
Achievements: 2x Rugby World Cups (2011, 2015), Rugby Championship titles, Super Rugby titles, Bledisloe Cup titles, 153 caps for New Zealand.
4. Sir Colin Meads (New Zealand)
Sir Colin Meads, a true pioneer of New Zealand rugby, laid the foundation for the modern game. Known for his uncompromising toughness and leadership, Meads was a dominant force in the lineout and was revered for his work ethic both in defense and attack. Meads played in an era before professional rugby, yet his influence is still felt today. His incredible versatility allowed him to contribute not only in set pieces but in open play as well. With 55 caps for New Zealand and being named New Zealand Rugby Player of the Century, Meads’ legacy will live on for generations.
Achievements: 55 caps for New Zealand, New Zealand Rugby Player of the Century (1999).
5. Nathan Sharpe (Australia)
Nathan Sharpe’s career epitomized reliability and consistency. Known for his leadership and tactical awareness, Sharpe was an anchor in the lineout and a crucial member of the Wallabies’ forward pack for over a decade. Despite flying under the radar compared to other locks, Sharpe’s ability to perform under pressure made him indispensable. His contribution to Australian rugby includes Bledisloe Cup titles and a Tri-Nations title. Sharpe earned 116 caps for Australia and played a vital role in the team’s success over the years.
Achievements: Bledisloe Cup titles, Tri-Nations title, 116 caps for Australia.
The #5 lock is one of the most crucial positions on the rugby field, and these players have more than earned their place in the spotlight. Victor Matfield’s mastery of the lineout, John Eales’ groundbreaking versatility, Sam Whitelock’s consistency, Colin Meads’ pioneering spirit, and Nathan Sharpe’s unwavering leadership have all shaped the game in ways that go far beyond individual accolades. Each of these legends played a key role in their teams’ successes, and their influence continues to resonate in the modern game. Their achievements set the standard for future generations of locks, and their legacies will endure as a testament to their greatness in the sport.