Continuing our series on the top five greatest players in each rugby position, we now shift our focus to the scrum-half. Often described as the heartbeat of the team, scrum-halves act as the crucial link between the forwards and backs. They’re the generals on the field—controlling tempo, dictating play, and making key tactical decisions under intense pressure. From lightning-quick passes to game-changing kicks and fearless defense, these players are indispensable to their teams’ success.
Here are five legendary scrum-halves who elevated the position and left an enduring mark on the game.
1. Joost van der Westhuizen (South Africa)
A fearless and dynamic force, Joost van der Westhuizen redefined what a scrum-half could be. Tall for the position, with a physical edge uncommon among No. 9s, he combined raw strength with blistering speed and instinctive attacking flair. Van der Westhuizen was pivotal in South Africa’s 1995 Rugby World Cup triumph, famously stopping Jonah Lomu in open play—a testament to his courage and tenacity. His influence extended beyond the field, becoming an iconic figure in South African rugby history.
Achievements: 1995 Rugby World Cup winner, inducted into World Rugby Hall of Fame, over 89 test caps for South Africa.
2. Gareth Edwards (Wales)
Widely regarded as one of the greatest rugby players of all time, Gareth Edwards was the complete scrum-half. He had it all—speed, vision, passing precision, and a nose for the dramatic. Edwards was a cornerstone of the dominant Welsh sides of the 1970s and a key figure in the British & Irish Lions’ legendary 1971 and 1974 tours. His try for the Barbarians against New Zealand in 1973 remains one of the most iconic moments in rugby history.
Achievements: Five Nations champion, British & Irish Lions legend, 53 test caps for Wales.
3. Fourie du Preez (South Africa)
Fourie du Preez was the tactical mastermind every coach dreams of. Calm under pressure and endlessly composed, he combined a sharp rugby brain with flawless execution. His box kicking, crisp passing, and defensive nous made him a central figure in South Africa’s 2007 Rugby World Cup win. Du Preez’s game management was second to none, and his ability to control matches made him a consistent match-winner.
Achievements: 2007 Rugby World Cup winner, Tri-Nations champion, Super Rugby winner, 76 test caps for South Africa.
4. George Gregan (Australia)
Australia’s most capped player, George Gregan brought unmatched consistency, professionalism, and competitiveness to the scrum-half role. Renowned for his rapid delivery, sharp wit, and tenacious defense, Gregan was instrumental in Australia’s golden era in the late 1990s and early 2000s. His leadership, especially as captain, helped steer the Wallabies to numerous memorable victories.
Achievements: 1999 Rugby World Cup winner, Tri-Nations champion, four-time Bledisloe Cup winner, 139 test caps for Australia.
5. Aaron Smith (New Zealand)
A modern maestro, Aaron Smith revolutionized the speed and accuracy of scrum-half play. Known for his bullet-fast pass and ability to spark attacking movements, Smith was a cornerstone of the All Blacks’ dynamic style during their dominant run through the 2010s. His work rate, communication, and precision under pressure set a new standard for the position.
Achievements: 2015 Rugby World Cup winner, multiple Rugby Championship titles, over 124 test caps for New Zealand.
These five scrum-halves exemplify everything the position demands—leadership, precision, toughness, and vision. Whether guiding their teams to World Cup glory or producing moments of genius, they’ve all helped redefine the role for generations to come.
Next in our series: we’ll be diving into the greatest fly-halves in rugby history—stay tuned!